Aligned with IEC and IEEE Standards
1. Introduction
The integration of Renewable Energy Systems (RES), such as Photovoltaic (PV) solar power, Wind Energy Conversion Systems (WECS), and Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS), into existing electrical networks necessitates a well-defined protection philosophy. This document presents a comprehensive strategy to ensure safety, reliability, and compliance with international standards. It addresses the specific requirements of renewable generation sources and provides guidelines for selecting, coordinating, and implementing protection schemes in alignment with IEC and IEEE standards.
2. Scope
This document applies to the protection of medium voltage (MV) and high voltage (HV) systems associated with renewable energy plants. It includes protection schemes from the inverter terminals up to the grid interconnection point, including associated transformers, feeders, switchgear, and energy storage units.
3. Applicable Standards
The following international standards form the basis for the protection philosophy outlined herein:
-
IEC 60255 - Measuring relays and protection equipment.
-
IEC 60909 - Short-circuit current calculation methods.
-
IEC 61000 series - Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC).
-
IEC 61727 - Interface requirements for PV systems.
-
IEC 62116 - Anti-islanding test procedures.
-
IEC 60364-7-712 - Electrical installations for PV systems.
-
IEC 62477 - Safety requirements for power converters.
-
IEC 61557-8/9 - Insulation monitoring and fault location.
-
IEEE 1547 - Standard for interconnection of distributed energy resources (DER).
-
IEEE C37.2 - Device function number standard.
-
IEEE C37.90 - Relays and relaying system performance.
-
IEEE C37.112 - Directional element operating characteristics.
-
IEEE 242 (Buff Book) - Protection and coordination of industrial systems.
-
IEEE 519 - Harmonic control in power systems.
4. Abbreviations and Definitions
| Abbreviation | Definition |
|---|---|
| BESS | Battery Energy Storage System |
| DER | Distributed Energy Resource |
| FRT | Fault Ride Through |
| GOOSE | Generic Object-Oriented Substation Event (IEC 61850) |
| HV | High Voltage |
| IED | Intelligent Electronic Device |
| IMD | Insulation Monitoring Device |
| IT System | Unearthed Electrical System |
| LV | Low Voltage |
| MV | Medium Voltage |
| NGR | Neutral Grounding Resistor |
| PV | Photovoltaic |
| ROCOF | Rate of Change of Frequency |
| RES | Renewable Energy System |
| SEF | Sensitive Earth Fault |
| SPD | Surge Protective Device |
| VT | Voltage Transformer |
| WECS | Wind Energy Conversion System |
5. System Overview
The protection system for a renewable energy plant encompasses various electrical zones, including inverter outputs, collector systems, transformers, and grid interconnection points. Each of these zones has specific protection requirements based on fault current levels, grounding schemes, system inertia, and equipment criticality. The philosophy considers protection for both AC and DC systems and incorporates requirements for BESS where applicable.
6. Protection Objectives
The main objectives of the protection system are to detect and isolate faults rapidly and selectively, ensure the safety of operating personnel and maintenance staff, protect critical and costly equipment, comply with grid codes, prevent unintentional islanding, and support grid stability and power quality. Protection must be coordinated to avoid unnecessary disconnection of generation and to enable fault ride-through capability as per local regulations.
7. Protection Zones and Schemes
7.1 Inverter Output (LV Side)
Inverters are protected against overcurrent, undervoltage, overvoltage, and anti-islanding conditions using device functions such as 50/51 (overcurrent), 27/59 (voltage), 81U/O (frequency), and ROCOF. These protections disconnect the inverter when grid parameters exceed permissible limits.
7.2 LV/MV Transformer Protection
Protection includes transformer differential (87T) for internal faults, Buchholz relay (63) for gas accumulation, overcurrent protection (50/51), and thermal overload protection (49). These measures prevent damage to transformer windings and cores.
7.3 MV Collector System
MV feeders are equipped with phase and ground overcurrent protection (50/51, 50N/51N), directional ground fault protection (67N, 67Q), and SEF schemes using CBCTs. Arc flash detection devices (AFDD) may also be employed in enclosed switchgear systems.
7.4 Main Transformer (Grid Tie)
The grid-tied main transformer is protected using differential protection (87T), restricted earth fault (64REF), surge protection (SPD), thermal overload (49), and neutral overvoltage (59N) protection. Fast isolation of transformer faults is critical for grid stability.
7.5 Grid Interconnection Point
At the point of common coupling (PCC), voltage (27, 59), frequency (81U/O), rate of change of frequency (81R), directional overcurrent (67), anti-islanding, and synchronization check (25) protections are applied. These functions ensure compliance with grid codes and maintain grid integrity.
7.6 Battery Energy Storage System (BESS)
For BESS, DC fault protection (50DC), insulation monitoring (IMD), overcharge/discharge control, and temperature monitoring (49, 63T) are implemented. Fault isolation and battery safety management are critical due to high energy densities involved.
8. Key Protection Functions
The protection philosophy incorporates the following key schemes:
-
Overcurrent Protection (50/51, 50N/51N) for detecting overload and short-circuit faults.
-
Directional Protection (67, 67N, 67Q) for radial or looped systems to prevent false tripping due to power flow reversals.
-
Distance Protection (21G) using Mho or Quadrilateral characteristics for HV transmission lines.
-
Differential Protection (87T) for internal faults in transformers and generators.
-
Voltage and Frequency Protection (27, 59, 81U/O) for grid parameter compliance.
-
ROCOF (81R) to detect islanding conditions.
-
Anti-Islanding Protection combining passive and active detection techniques, as defined in IEC 62116 and IEEE 1547.
-
Insulation Monitoring using IMDs in IT systems, compliant with IEC 61557-8.
9. Protection Coordination Philosophy
Protection coordination is achieved through time-graded and zone-based schemes. Inverter protection acts instantaneously, while feeder and transformer protections are coordinated to clear faults selectively. High-speed differential and REF protections override delayed overcurrent relays. Protection settings follow short-circuit analysis per IEC 60909 and manufacturer thermal withstand limits. Coordination is verified using protection study software with relay setting files reviewed prior to commissioning.
10. Communication and SCADA Integration
All protection IEDs must comply with IEC 61850, supporting:
-
GOOSE messaging for high-speed tripping and interlocking.
-
MMS (Manufacturing Message Specification) for SCADA integration.
-
Time synchronization via IEEE 1588 Precision Time Protocol (PTP).
The protection system must support real-time monitoring, remote testing, and automatic event reporting for post-fault diagnostics.
11. Fault Ride-Through and Grid Support
In compliance with IEEE 1547-2018 and local grid codes, RES must remain connected during voltage and frequency disturbances unless equipment limits are exceeded. Inverters and BESS must support fault ride-through capability, provide reactive power during faults, and follow ramp rate limits for active power injection. These features improve voltage stability and mitigate fault propagation.
12. Maintenance, Testing, and Monitoring
All protection devices undergo Factory Acceptance Tests (FAT), Site Acceptance Tests (SAT), and commissioning tests, including current injection and functional validation. Routine periodic testing ensures long-term system reliability. Event recorders and disturbance monitors should be configured to store high-resolution data for fault analysis.
13. Cybersecurity and Redundancy
Protection and communication systems must comply with IEC 62351 and NERC-CIP cybersecurity guidelines. Role-based access control, secure protocols (TLS), and tamper-proof logging are required. Critical zones (e.g., main transformer, grid tie) shall have redundant protection relays and communication paths to ensure operational reliability.
14. Conclusion
A robust and standards-compliant protection philosophy is essential for integrating renewable energy sources into power systems. By aligning with IEEE and IEC guidelines, this strategy ensures the safe operation of RES, facilitates grid code compliance, and supports a reliable and sustainable power grid. Continued monitoring, coordination, and system upgrades are essential to adapt to evolving renewable integration requirements.